Semi-Variable Costs: When Costs Don’t Fit Neatly

In business, costs can be categorized in different ways, depending on the perspective you take:

• Fixed vs. Variable Costs focus on cost behavior—whether an expense stays the same or fluctuates with sales or production volume.
• Direct vs. Indirect Costs focus on causality—whether a cost can be traced directly to a product or must be allocated across multiple products or departments.

Many costs fit neatly into these categories, but some don’t. Semi-variable costs have both fixed and variable components, making them an important consideration for budgeting, pricing, and financial planning. Understanding these costs helps businesses make better financial decisions, control expenses, and anticipate cost changes as they scale.

Cost Behavior vs. Cost Causality

While fixed vs. variable and direct vs. indirect are often discussed together, they serve different purposes:

• Fixed vs. Variable Costs (Cost Behavior) – Examines how a cost changes based on sales or production volume.
• Direct vs. Indirect Costs (Cost Causality) – Determines whether a cost is directly caused by a specific product or allocated across multiple products.

These classifications often overlap. For example:

• Raw materials are variable (change with production volume) and direct (traceable to a product).
• Rent is fixed (same cost every month) and indirect (supports the entire business).

This distinction matters because some costs behave differently over time, and failing to account for this can lead to miscalculations in pricing, profitability, and financial forecasting.

Why “Semi-Direct” Costs Don’t Exist

Some costs may seem partially direct, but in accounting, a cost is either product-related or it isn’t—there’s no such thing as a semi-direct cost.

Instead, businesses allocate indirect costs using a fountain model, where expenses are first assigned directly to products, then allocated to product groups, and finally distributed across the organization. A cost that is not directly caused by a single product but is associated with a product group remains indirect, not semi-direct.

For example:

• Raw materials for a specific product = Direct cost
• Factory utilities supporting multiple products = Indirect cost

While semi-direct is a misnomer, what does exist are semi-variable costs—expenses that behave as fixed within certain limits but shift to variable beyond those limits.

Two Types of Semi-Variable Costs

1. Stepwise Variable Costs (Type A)

These costs remain constant over a given range of production but increase in steps when production exceeds a threshold.

• Example: A factory running a single shift has stable labor and overhead costs, but when demand rises, adding a second shift or additional equipment leads to a stepwise increase in costs.

Common examples include:

• Manufacturing overhead (additional shifts, production lines, or machines).
• Warehouse and logistics costs (leasing more storage or adding distribution capacity).
• Supervisory or administrative labor that expands at key growth points.

2. Base-Level Plus Variable Costs (Type B)

These costs have a fixed base amount and increase gradually based on usage.

• Example: An electricity bill with a fixed monthly connection fee plus a variable charge per unit consumed.

Other examples include:

• Sales commissions with a base salary plus performance-based bonuses.
• Equipment maintenance contracts with a minimum service fee plus additional charges based on usage.
• Software subscriptions that charge a base rate but increase with additional users or data storage.

Why Understanding Semi-Variable Costs Matters

Recognizing semi-variable costs is critical for:

• Accurate pricing – Accounting for cost jumps ensures profitability.
• Better budgeting and forecasting – Predicting when costs will rise helps businesses plan ahead.
• Cost control – Identifying when and why costs increase allows for proactive management.
• Smarter scaling decisions – Knowing when additional capacity is needed helps businesses expand efficiently.

Final Thoughts: Smarter Cost Management for Better Decisions

Understanding cost structures isn’t just about classification—it’s about making better business decisions. Whether a cost is fixed, variable, or semi-variable, the key is knowing:

• Where you have control – Which costs can be reduced, renegotiated, or optimized?
• When costs will change – Do certain costs step up at predictable thresholds? Are there hidden cost drivers?
• How costs impact pricing and profitability – Are you factoring in all costs when setting prices and making long-term financial plans?

Businesses that actively manage costs—rather than just tracking them—are better positioned to scale efficiently, maintain profitability, and respond strategically to changing conditions.

The real challenge isn’t just classifying costs—it’s using that knowledge to drive smarter financial decisions at every level of the business.

Want to strengthen financial understanding across your team? Explore our business acumen training.

‍

‍

You've seen how business decisions play out in Income|Outcome—now apply it to your own work.

• Look at the costs in your department: Which ones are flexible? Where do you have control?
• Are there semi-variable costs that impact your ability to scale?
• If you were optimizing costs, what would be your first move?

As part of our upcoming ROI Playbook, we’ll share a framework to help you map business decisions to financial impact. Start now by identifying one cost category where a small change could create measurable improvements.

‍